Businesses Face Growing Exposure as Inaccurate Product Data Triggers Contract and Compliance Disputes

UK businesses are facing increased commercial and regulatory risk due to poor quality control over product and specification data, according to advisers and auditors working across manufacturing, retail and business-to-business supply chains.

The issue centres on inaccurate, inconsistent or outdated product information being passed between organisations, leading to disputes over conformity, performance and contractual compliance.

Industry bodies say the problem has intensified as supply chains become more digital and decentralised. Product specifications, drawings, bills of materials and technical data sheets are now routinely shared across multiple systems, platforms and partners. Where controls are weak, discrepancies can arise between what was ordered, what was produced and what was ultimately delivered.

Quality professionals report that audits increasingly uncover gaps in version control and approval of technical information. In several recent commercial disputes reviewed by legal advisers, businesses were unable to demonstrate which specification was contractually valid at the point of manufacture. In some cases, suppliers were working to superseded drawings or incomplete data sets, while customers believed updated requirements had been implemented.

“Data accuracy has become a quality risk in its own right,” said Andrew Milner, a quality and compliance consultant advising mid-sized manufacturers. “When product data is fragmented across email, shared drives and supplier portals, organisations lose confidence that everyone is working to the same requirements. That’s when disputes and nonconformities start to emerge.”

The issue is not confined to physical manufacturing. Service providers, software developers and engineering consultancies are also reporting quality failures linked to poorly controlled requirements and specifications. Clients have raised concerns where delivered services did not align with agreed scopes, only for suppliers to discover that requirement changes had not been formally captured or approved.

Regulators and standards bodies have also noted the trend. The Chartered Quality Institute has warned that weak information governance can undermine otherwise mature quality management systems. A spokesperson said organisations are increasingly being assessed not just on whether processes exist, but on whether information supporting those processes is accurate, current and demonstrably controlled.

Commercial impacts can be significant. Businesses report increased rework, delayed deliveries, rejected outputs and strained customer relationships when specification errors are discovered late. In regulated sectors, inaccurate product data can also lead to compliance breaches, particularly where certification, testing or conformity marking is involved.

Some organisations are responding by tightening document control, introducing master data ownership roles and implementing formal change-control workflows across supplier interfaces. Others are carrying out targeted internal audits focused specifically on data accuracy rather than physical product inspection.

Quality specialists say the growing focus reflects a shift in how quality is assessed in modern organisations. “Quality failures are no longer always visible on the factory floor,” Milner added. “They often originate much earlier, in how requirements are defined, communicated and maintained. If the data is wrong, the outcome will be wrong - no matter how good the process looks on paper.”

As digital integration between businesses continues to expand, expectations around data accuracy and traceability are likely to harden. For organisations operating under quality management systems such as ISO 9001, the ability to demonstrate control over product and service information is increasingly becoming a defining measure of quality maturity.

A message from our sponsors, The Ideas Distillery: 

If you would like to look at how to implement an ISO 9001 quality management system, then simply contact us.

Or, if you want to see what's involved in more detail, then get a completely free, no obligation, totally tailored ISO Gap Analysis for your business (only available to UK businesses).